Potbelly Underground Menu (Updated 2026)

The Potbelly Underground Menu is a secret list of food items that are not shown on the regular menu. Many Potbelly fans enjoy ordering from this menu because it feels special and different. Not every store may offer all underground items, but staff will often make them if you ask nicely.

This hidden menu makes eating at Potbelly more fun and exciting. You can try new flavors, add extra meat, or choose special topping combinations. If you like trying something new, the Potbelly Underground Menu is a great way to enjoy a fresh and tasty sandwich experience.

Underground Potbelly Menu

The Potbelly Underground Menu is a special set of sandwich options that are not listed on the regular menu. These items are made by customizing popular sandwiches with extra meat, different breads, or special topping combinations. Many customers enjoy ordering from the underground menu because it lets them try new flavors and enjoy a more personal meal. Availability can change by location, but asking politely often helps you get these hidden menu items.

Potbelly Menu Underground

Main Underground Menu Potbelly

Item NameCaloriesPrice
Fireball717 cal$5.80
Wrecking Ball845 cal$7.65
Lucky 7836 cal$7.65
Clubby664 cal$6.25
Sicilian850 cal$6.25
Cheeseburger642 cal$5.00
The Barnyard735 cal$7.70
Black and Bleu548 cal$5.00
Chicken Cordon Bleu498 cal$6.45
Elvis780 cal$6.10
Toasty Turkey BLT624 cal$6.00

How to Order from the Potbelly Underground Menu

Ordering from the Potbelly Underground Menu is easy if you keep it simple. First, know the name of the sandwich you want or remember the main ingredients. When you order, politely ask the staff if they can make it for you. Because these items are not on the regular menu, being kind and clear really helps.

You can also create the sandwich yourself. Pick a regular sandwich and ask to add extra meat, cheese, or toppings. Prices may be higher because of additional items, and not every store makes all underground sandwiches. Just ask nicely and enjoy trying something new.

Tips to Get the Best Experience

To get the best experience at Potbelly, always be polite and friendly when ordering, especially if you are asking for an underground menu item. Being patient and relaxed will make the process smooth and enjoyable. It is also a good idea to visit during less busy hours, so the staff have more time to help you customize your sandwich. Lastly, remember that prices and availability can vary by location, so keep an open mind and enjoy the fun of trying something new.

Frequently Asked Question(FAQs)

Yes, it’s real but unofficial. It’s based on custom orders using existing ingredients.

Most locations allow it, but flexibility depends on staff and store policy.

Only if you add extra meat or cheese, otherwise, prices are similar.

Yes. You can create many veggie-based custom sandwiches.

Conclusion

The Potbelly Underground Menu is a fun way to enjoy something different from the regular menu. By asking nicely and keeping your order simple, you can try new sandwich flavors made just the way you like. Overall, it’s a great way to make your Potbelly visit more exciting and tasty.