Potbelly Cookies & Shakes Menu Prices (Updated 2026)

Potbelly Cookies & Shakes are sweet and tasty treats. Potbelly cookies are soft, fresh, and baked every day. You can enjoy flavors like chocolate chip, oatmeal chocolate chip, and sugar cookies. Many people like to eat a potbelly cookie after their sandwich or as a small snack.

Potbelly shakes are thick, cold, and very creamy. Potbelly shake are made with real ice cream and come in simple flavors like chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry. These shakes are perfect for hot days or when you want something sweet. Cookies and shakes at Potbelly make your meal more fun.

Potbelly Cookies and Shakes Menu with Prices

The Potbelly Cookies and Shakes menu offers simple, sweet items at fair prices. Fresh-baked cookies like Chocolate Brownie Cookie, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, and Sugar Cookie usually cost around $2.39 each. The hand-dipped milkshakes are thick and creamy and come in flavors such as Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and Oreo®, with an average price of about $5.29. These cookies and shakes are a tasty and affordable way to finish your meal at Potbelly.

Eggnog Shake

$5.59 | 760 cal

6-Pack Cookie Box

$11.89 | 420 cal

Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie

$2.39 | 420 cal

Sugar Cookie

$2.39 | 520 cal

Chocolate Brownie Cookie

$2.39 | 420 cal

Dream Bar

$2.59 | 430 cal

Bag of Mini Cookies

$5.19 | 1150 cal

Banana Pudding Shake

$5.59 | 710 cal

Cold Brew Shake

$5.59 | 770 cal

OREO® Cookie Shake

$5.59 | 769 cal

Chocolate Shake

$5.29 | 773 cal

Strawberry Shake

$5.29 | 745 cal

Vanilla Shake

$5.29 | 698 cal

Why People Love Potbelly Cookies and Shakes

People love Potbelly cookies and shakes because they are made fresh and taste homemade. The cookies are soft and warm, while the shakes are thick and filling. These desserts are perfect for ending a meal or enjoying a treat anytime. Potbelly also keeps the menu simple, which makes it easy to choose your favorite flavor.

Tips to Enjoy Potbelly Cookies Shakes

Try warm cookies – Freshly baked cookies taste best when they are soft and warm. Ask if they have just baked ones for the best flavor.
Pair cookies with a shake – Dip your cookie in a milkshake for a fun and extra tasty experience.
Mix shake flavors – Don’t be afraid to try different shake flavors or mix two for a new taste.
Share with friends – Cookies and shakes are perfect to enjoy with friends or family.
Enjoy slowly – Take small bites and sips to really enjoy the creamy shakes and soft cookies.

Frequently Asked Question(FAQs)

Potbelly offers Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, and Sugar Cookies.

You can get Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, and Oreo® shakes.

Yes, you can order them for takeout or eat in the store.

Yes, Potbelly shakes are made with real, creamy ice cream.

Conclusion

The Potbelly Cookies and Shakes menu is a great choice for dessert lovers. With fresh cookies and creamy shakes, Potbelly offers sweet treats that are affordable and delicious. If you are visiting Potbelly, don’t forget to try a cookie or shake to complete your meal. With great flavors and fresh ingredients, Potbelly makes dessert time simple and fun for all ages.